The deluxe version of dodie’s 2025 record showcases hopefulness in sorrow with extra clarinets and fresh new harmonies.
The deluxe version of dodie’s 2025 record showcases hopefulness in sorrow with extra clarinets and fresh new harmonies.
Making her start by posting ukulele songs to her YouTube channel 15 years ago, dodie has made a career from quirky, upbeat love songs to jazzy, harmony-layered melodies about her journey with her mental health.
In October 2025, the English artist released her second studio album, “Not For Lack of Trying.” This October, she released the deluxe version, adding an additional seven songs to the original 12.
Setting the tone for the rest of the album in opener “I’M FINE!,” dodie repeats to her audience just that: she’s fine. Surrounded by almost-haunting violins and phrases full of anxious panic — “One year left to figure it out,” “To overthink and tailspin,” — the song ironically portrays the opposite of its title.
The second song of the album, “Smart Girl,” reveals dodie’s struggles with jealousy and perceptions of herself as an artist. The track begins with a melody precariously held together by light, airy vocals and eventually dissolves into chaotic tunes over loud instruments.
Switching to a lighter mood, the third song brings on friend and fellow member of indie pop band Fizz, Greta Isaac, to sing with dodie about their cat. “Darling, Angel, Baby” encapsulates the feeling cat-owners know too well, filled with harmonic meows and words of immense devotion.
“Hold Fire” and “Tall Kids” are the next up, discussing insecurities and struggles the 31-year-old has faced. The former relays her struggle to grasp seemingly obscure social expectations and the latter depicts her desire to be seen as a child.
“Make me magic / Make them care / I’ll keep praying / Is that fair?” dodie sings, questioning, in “Tall Kids.”
“I Feel Bad For You, Dave” holds a snappy, jazzy drum throughout, conveying the struggles of dating in the online world, as well as the impact of sharing controversial opinions on the internet. Furthermore, the song depicts the realities of dating men in a world where misogyny is rampant and accepted in an online setting.
A standout on the album, “Now” hands the listener a cup of tea radiating warm, musical steam.
“One day, far away, bad things come / But that’s not now / Waves come, they will go, and come again / But that’s not now,” dodie sings, the song finishing with reassurance that while much of her music understands life’s struggles, there’s light to be found.
With soft piano in the forefront of the album’s eighth track, “The List” recaps the experience of moving on after a relationship. “Different” follows similarly, with piano shaping the vocals that look back on the way people from the past are perceived.
When faced with tragedy, the world can often feel like “The End.” The 10th track shares the enormity emotions can take up when forced to face loss or grief.
“It’s a death, it’s the end / I’ll never see you like this again,” the indie songwriter sings, while the squeak of fingers sliding on guitar fretboards fills the air.
There is, however, a light at the end of the tunnel as the album continues into its next song.
“The Answer” shakes up the largely melancholic album with quite an upbeat tune, imploring the listener to “skip three times on your way to anywhere,” and the snazzy beat makes it more than easy to do so.
The final song on the original version of the album, “Not For Lack Of Trying,” brings the record together. It has all the warmth of “Now,” but maintains the anxieties that make the album relatable.
The most poignant part of the final song is the hope that comes from the swing of emotions in the album. It represents what it is to face life’s gloom and understand there’s also joy.
The album’s deluxe version holds three new songs, as well as four live versions of original album tracks with brand new backing vocals and instruments. This version brings new desires and a sense of serenity, while also presenting a new angle for interpretation with the live versions. On top of this, the deluxe version was born out of dodie’s lifelong love of the clarinet and a desire to put more of it in her music.
The first new song, “Maybe, Finally,” carries much of the hope of the previous song, describing the feeling of finally finding some peace while simultaneously being afraid to take it in as much as possible, lest it slip away too soon.
Final bonus tracks “Fruit in the Sun” and “As Far As We Know” exist almost as reflections of each other. “Fruit in the Sun” showcases an unwelcome — or even indulgent — desire to stay put, while “As Far As We Know” represents a desire to move and grow.
The final four tracks of the deluxe album are upbeat, clarinet-heavy renditions of “The List,” “Smart Girl,” “Dave, I Feel Bad For You” and “The Answer.” Each song truly captures the joy music carries inherently, even when the material is often used to express heavy emotions.
dodie’s second album is something that anyone who’s experienced joy, grief or hope might find some light in. “Not For Lack Of Trying (Deluxe)” is written as a message to herself, a call to seek hope and love even in the face of sorrow.
Whether seeking light or facing the dark, “Not For Lack Of Trying (Deluxe)” is a reminder that hope unfound is not for lack of trying.
‘Not For Lack Of Trying (Deluxe)’ is available to stream everywhere.