Stick to policy, not parents: Leave behind political attack ads

Attack ads have become increasingly common in recent elections, despite the harm they pose to many candidates.

Vivek Ramaswamy published a controversial ad attacking his opponent. (Sophia Reass | The Phoenix)
Vivek Ramaswamy published a controversial ad attacking his opponent. (Sophia Reass | The Phoenix)

The spending on this year’s political advertisements has surpassed any previous midterm election and the 2024 presidential election at $11.21 billion, according to The Wrap. The goal of these ads is to entice citizens to vote for a specific candidate, though the narratives behind each ad can be vastly different.

There are biography ads, which introduce a candidate, and comparison ads which emphasize the belief differences between two candidates, but the phenomenon takes its most harmful form in attack ads. 

These ads focus a critical lens on an opponent’s past, their public statements, perceived failures or moral character. Attack ads often take a phrase or quote out of context and vilify it, or be hypercritical of a specific and often extreme policy the candidate supports. 

In this midterm election, attack ads crossed the line between political rivalry and personal strikes.

An extreme example was highlighted in the Ohio governor race between Republican candidate Vivek Ramaswamy and Democratic candidate Amy Acton. 

Ramaswamy released a campaign video criticizing Acton’s credibility by weaponizing her estranged mother. Acton was removed from her household when she was 12 years old after being sexually abused and raped by her stepfather. Her mother chose to stay with Acton’s stepfather, leaving Acton to move in with her biological father. 

The ad features Acton’s mother claiming her daughter is a liar, according to NPR. She also encouraged people not to vote for Acton. When this ad was aired, it gave no context or background into Acton’s relationship with her mother, nor did it mention the abuse she lived through as a child. 

The ad calls into question the ethical responsibility candidates owe each other when publishing media to further their campaign agenda. Attack ads targeting moral character are one thing, but using an opponent’s disclosure of childhood rape as political ammunition is another.

As someone who has an estranged relationship with a parent, I can only imagine how demoralizing it would be to stand in front of voters and explain and defend my side of the story. It’s very hard to understand other people’s family ties, and politicians shouldn’t be required to publicly dissect their childhood trauma to save their image just because they’re public figures.

I haven’t been in contact with one of my parents for a few years now, and I would feel absolutely betrayed and isolated if my past had been dug up — most people would. I also know how trauma-inducing it can be to have the past sprung on you with no notice, there should be no room for that in politics. 

Candidates from both parties, Democrat and Republican, have condemned the video and called for it to be taken down, though Ramaswamy has only held firm, adding more funding to keep it running through its cycle, which has now concluded and the campaign has moved on to other ads. 

Being called out by the Democratic Party is common for Ramaswamy, but it’s unusual for him to be called out by his own party. 

When reaching into candidates’ pasts, the line of morality often gets blurred, but it’s hard to see any world in which an ad using Acton’s mother ––– who was present and was complicit in Acton’s abuse ––– would ever be seen as a good, credible idea. 

The preposterous ad makes Ramaswamy less credible than Acton because it proves he’s reaching to extremes to gain votes.

Acton responded mainly through a video of her brother, who was also abused, talking about how awful it was. While she’s still running her campaign and has gained traction since the ad, it comes with a cost. The only reason I knew who she was, given I’m from Minnesota, is because of the controversy around the ad, not because of her beliefs, motivations or campaign. 

Attack ads have long been used to target opposing candidates, but directly targeting a familial relationship with trauma and non-public context crosses a personal and professional line. Regardless of backlash to Ramaswamy and Acton now being favored to win the governor’s race, ridiculing past trauma to get ahead is morally corrupt and shouldn’t have a place in politics. 

When creating ads, candidates should stick to policy, not parents.

  • Molly Hanley

    Molly Hanley is a first-year student studying political science and film and is originally from Saint Paul, MN. This is her first year on staff with The Phoenix as a staff writer. When not writing, she enjoys watching soccer with her dad, playing volleyball, baking various sweet treats and reading ridiculously long books.

    View all posts

Tags

Get the Loyola Phoenix newsletter straight to your inbox!

Maroon-Phoenix-logo-3

SPONSORED

Latest