The Editors Discuss: When to listen to Christmas music

Start listening Nov. 1 It’s Sunday, Nov. 1. I’ve just folded up my Halloween costume, shoving capes and animal ears into my closet, and I’m about to give my bedroom a deep clean it hasn’t seen all October.  I light a candle, and I turn on my Christmas music. This year, I started strong with …

A brightly-lit house in Chicagoland area (Dylan Eckhardt |The Phoenix)
A brightly-lit house in Chicagoland area (Dylan Eckhardt |The Phoenix)

Start listening Nov. 1

It’s Sunday, Nov. 1. I’ve just folded up my Halloween costume, shoving capes and animal ears into my closet, and I’m about to give my bedroom a deep clean it hasn’t seen all October. 

I light a candle, and I turn on my Christmas music. This year, I started strong with Nat King Cole. 

Admittedly, I always feel a little crazy doing this and ignoring the pleas of horror from my roommates who beg me to use headphones. This year, I’d barely shaken off my Halloweekend haze before switching on Mariah Carey, and I could still see orange buckets of candy sitting on the doorsteps of my neighbors’ buildings. 

November is a rough month, especially for college kids, and I need to cling to any ounce of joy I can find if I want to make it three more weeks until Thanksgiving break. The sweet nostalgia and childlike glee I gain from a few corny Christmas verses make the final grueling weeks finishing out the semester a bit more manageable despite the ridiculousness.

I haven’t visited home since July, and it’s been nearly a year since I’ve seen most of my extended family. With three editions of The Phoenix, six papers, countless assignments and a half dozen finals between me and relaxing with my loved ones, I need a reminder that there’s a world beyond Loyola where my mom is carefully arranging the decorations of the mantel and my uncles have “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation” on repeat. 

And don’t for one second think I’m forgetting about Thanksgiving. The meal of the year is no small event, but I believe Christmas music is the perfect soundtrack for a Turkey Day dinner. Listening to a little Ella Fitzgerald while scarfing down my mashed potatoes doesn’t devalue the revered holiday. 

With the city lit up by colored bulbs and the end of the semester in sight, December has plenty of opportunities for childish joy, but midwestern November is dull. The sun sets at 4 p.m., the trees lose their October colors and the first snowfall rarely sticks, leaving the world gray, empty and lifeless. 

I should be allowed to rectify this depressing month by pressing play on my Christmas playlist a little early. Sue me.

(Luke Larimer | The Phoenix)

Start listening Dec. 1

By Carlos Soto-Angulo

For most of my childhood, my parents only played SiriusXM’s Top 40 Hits on the car ride to school and home. Around the time of Thanksgiving, the DJs would start to play familiar Christmas tunes, and I, like every other kid, sang along with joy, knowing that Santa would soon bring me the XBOX I’d been asking for all year. 

After two months of listening to the same Wham! song every morning and afternoon, I stopped believing in Santa.  

There’s a time and place for everything, and Christmas music is no exception. As tempting as it may be to defrost Mariah Carey as soon as Halloween ends, one should let November have its moment. Christmas will come, whether the festivity begins in November or not — there’s no reason to rush it. 

Christmas music carries a certain magic, largely because it’s limited to a particular time of year. Hearing Bing Crosby’s “White Christmas” feels like revisiting an old friend. “The Christmas Song” off of Paul McCartney’s “Kisses On The Bottom” reminds me of sitting with my grandfather in the living room. But when those same songs have been playing for two months, their charm starts to wear thin. Part of the excitement comes from knowing the season has finally arrived. 

November deserves some recognition, too. Thanksgiving has become an unfortunate casualty of the annual Christmas takeover, between Halloween decorations coming down and department stores putting up their artificial pine trees.

Between football games, family dinners filled with political banter and “the cousin walk,” the holiday offers plenty of reasons to celebrate without borrowing another’s soundtrack. 

There’s also something satisfying about the gradual transition from fall to winter. The first genuinely cold morning — or 65-degree day in Miami — and the changing decorations around the neighborhood signal the approaching holiday season. 

Of course, nobody should be forbidden from listening to Christmas music whenever they please, and I spent most of my life viewing winter as mostly symbolic, so take my argument with a grain of salt. 

However, December is only four weeks, so I say we should let it have its soundtrack. When it arrives, the bells can ring, Mariah can arise and Michael Bublé can emerge from hibernation. Until then, let November have its time in the spotlight. 

After all, Christmas isn’t going anywhere.

  • Julia Pentasuglio

    Julia Pentasuglio is The Phoenix’s editor-in-chief. She is a fourth-year majoring in multimedia journalism and political science with a minor in environmental communication. Outside of Loyola, Julia interned for The Spokesman-Review in Spokane, Wash. and the Akron Beacon Journal in Akron, Ohio. She has also worked on the Digital Media team at North Coast Media, a business-to-business magazine company based in Cleveland, Ohio. Julia enjoys writing about energy and environmental issues, parks and recreation and local politics. Outside of her love for news and investigative storytelling, Julia enjoys camping, biking, skiing and anything she can do outside. Got a story tip? Email Julia at jpentasuglio@luc.edu or DM @jpentasugliowrites on Instagram.

    View all posts
  • Carlos Soto-Angulo

    Carlos is the opinion editor and a second-year political science and philosophy double major. He first started his journalism career centered around broadcast and fell in love with print writing before joining The Phoenix. Outside of the paper, he likes to listen to his cassette tapes and CDs, read hardcover books and play Skate 3, but not all at the same time. 

    View all posts

Tags

Get the Loyola Phoenix newsletter straight to your inbox!

Maroon-Phoenix-logo-3

SPONSORED

Latest