Stingy owners and wage disparities: MLB salary cap controversy

Deputy Sports Editor Alejandra Pina and writer Dominic Taylor debate the existence of the MLB salary cap.

(Henry Barwick | The Phoenix)
(Henry Barwick | The Phoenix)

Pro Salary cap

By Alejandra Pina

With the end of the 2026 MLB season, some fans are already gearing up to watch their favorite teams play out another 162 games — even the players are ready to take on 2027. MVP winner Chicago Cubs centerfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong said it best: “I love looking forward to the next season.”

But what if there isn’t a next season?

The collective bargaining agreement (CBA) set between the MLB Players Association and the team owners represented by the league is set to expire Dec. 1. The contract is considered “the central labor pact,” which, in short, means it covers players’ salary.

If an agreement isn’t reached by the deadline, the most likely scenario we’ll see play out is a lockout. MLB owners could prevent all league business from occurring, including a no-contact rule between athletes and coaches, until the contract is decided.

With the imminent expiration of the CBA, the players union and team owners have been negotiating what the new deal will look like. The most contentious issue, preventing an agreement between the two sides, is the proposal to enforce a salary cap of $258.2 million with a floor of $180.2 million.

To put this into perspective, players like Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher and designated hitter Shohei Ohtani or New York Mets left fielder Juan Soto  — the two highest paid players in the league — wouldn’t be able to hold a $700 million contract.

I know this is a “low-hanging fruit” argument, but let’s be serious — a baseball player doesn’t need to be paid hundreds of millions of dollars, even if you’re a two-position superstar like Ohtani.

Without a cap, the league faces a major wage disparity, with the Mets spending the most in 2026 with a payroll of over $300 million, and the Guardians paying significantly less, sitting just under $70 million.  

This, in part, perpetuates a longstanding problem between small market teams and their larger counterparts like the Cleveland Guardians and the Dodgers. Sure, the owners are partly to blame as it comes down to how much they’re willing to spend on trades and payroll, but an enforced ceiling would help prevent such discrepancies.

The Guardians’ highest paid player in 2026 was third baseman Jose Ramirez, who has a contract of $26 million — about 8.7% of Soto’s entire salary.

Hailing from a family of Chicago baseball fans, I’d personally love to stop hearing my brothers complain about how Cubs owner Thomas Ricketts is failing the team by not spending as much as he should be.

“Everyone hates on the Dodgers, myself included, but I only wish Ricketts wasn’t a cheap prick or else we’d be winning too,” a passionate brother of mine said.

For a team that’s only won the World Series three times, two of them being in the early 20th century, compared to the Dodgers’ nine wins, you’d think Ricketts would be willing to pick up the high-cost players — but that’s an argument for another article.

Many fans believe a cap isn’t necessary and what’s needed is a floor, but I believe a balance needs to be struck — I don’t think you can have one without the other.

A floor ensures owners like Rickett will spend more while owners like Dodgers’ Guggenheim Baseball Management will even the playing field and pay less. This would lead to a more competitive market at trade deadlines, and wouldn’t that be more entertaining?

The MLB is the only American professional sports league that doesn’t have a cap on its players wages. For the 2026-2027 season, the NBA has a ceiling of $164.961 million while the NFL’s sits at $301.2 million.

Even if this past World Series is proof small market teams like Milwaukee and Tampa Bay can make it to the top of the league and win, it’s obvious there are still major payroll disparities that need to be leveled out.

So, while the shadow of an expiration slowly encroaches onto the MLB postseason, and the idea of a lockout becomes reality, I will sit back and watch with many other fans as negotiations continue to play out.

Anti Salary cap

By Dominic Taylor

As the Major League Baseball (MLB) World Series comes to a close every year, front offices across the league prepare to make moves either improving, retaining or flat-out blowing up their entire rosters before the start of the next season in March. This season, front offices and league officials have more to worry about than their own operations. The MLB’s collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, inspiring lots of speculation about a lockout. 

One of the spotlighted issues in this year’s installment of negotiations is the idea of a league-wide salary cap. Almost every other professional sports league in America has one, so why not the MLB?

It would supposedly prevent the greedy Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Mets from stealing all the best players in the league from teams like the 2026 World Series Champion Milwaukee Brewers and World Series runner-up Tampa Bay Rays.

Although the results of the World Series say otherwise, high-spending teams do inherently have an advantage over lower-spending clubs, no matter how many times they watch “Moneyball.” Despite a salary cap being the common-sense solution to this problem, the real answer is actually the opposite. 

Regardless of fans’ opinions, the players aren’t the ones who support the salary cap. In fact, the MLB’s Player Association strongly opposes this legislation. The owners of these teams are the strongest proponents of a cap on player spending. 

Owners want this, so they don’t have to pay their players in order to win. The Mets are often criticized for unfairly spending money on players, but the Chicago Cubs actually had more revenue in 2026 than the Mets. 

New York was just willing to pay their players a more fair share of the revenue. Chicago used about 42% of their earnings on their roster, while New York spent 20 points higher, around 62%. If a fanbase is complaining that their small-market team can’t spend any more money, it’s likely the fault of ownership, not the spending habits of the fanbase. 

Even though it’s been proven that you don’t have to spend big to win big, uneven spending is undoubtedly a problem across baseball. A salary cap theoretically would solve this, but a salary floor would be much more effective in ensuring players get their fair share of pay while owners are forced to spend money on teams with fanbases that would pay so much more to see their team win. 

I believe a salary cap is a step in the exact wrong direction for the MLB. It promotes a less player-orientated league, and benefits no one but the wealthy owners at the top.

It’s time to stop blaming teams like the Dodgers for caring about the success of their team, and start holding stingy owners accountable for their subpar investments in their team.

Tags

Get the Loyola Phoenix newsletter straight to your inbox!

Maroon-Phoenix-logo-3

SPONSORED

Latest